By Ellen Tordesillas, VERA Files
DFA’s failure to relay China’s message to Malacañang that Aquino visit “at a more conducive time” and send instead Trade Secretary Gregory Domingo had put the President in an embarrassing situation as he announced on Aug. 28 his trip to Nanning, Guangxi, site of this year’s Expo.
In a media briefing, Foreign Affairs Spokesman Raul Hernandez read a five-point Question and Answer and did not entertain questions.
The Q &A insisted that Aquino was invited by China, belying a statement by the Chinese Foreign Ministry that “China never extended an invitation to the Philippine president.”
Hernandez referred reporters to China’s note verbale to the Association of Southeast Asian Nations sent through this year’s coordinator, Thailand, saying “it is our sincere hope that the leaders of the 10 ASEAN members states would make their presence at the 10th CAEXPO.”
Earlier, Hernandez said, “The invitation was to the country, to the Philippines, requesting that we send a high-level delegation to the CAEXPO in Nanning.”
The Q & A also said, “There were subsequent concerns and conditions to the President’s attendance and such conditions were absolutely inimical to our national interest.”
“The President stood firm in the defense of the country’s national interest,” the DFA said. What it did not explain was why Aquino initially accepted and announced his visit if he had found the conditions against the national interest.
The DFA would not reveal the conditions “to avoid embarrassment on the Chinese side.”
Hernandez said the conditions were relayed by “at least three Chinese Foreign Ministry sources” who said the conditions should not be made public and should not be discussed at ministerial level.
“Given the unusual request and the importance of the issue involving our President, it was necessary for the conditions to be confirmed by the two Foreign Ministers at their meeting in Beijing last Wednesday, 28 August 2013,” the Q and A said.
VERA Files reported Monday that on July 24, Foreign Affairs Undersecretary Evan Garcia informed Chinese Ambassador Ma Keqing that Aquino wants to visit China.
Garcia and Chinese Vice Foreign Minister Liu Zhenmin met in Hong Kong to discuss Aquino’s possible China visit including attendance at the Nanning CAEXPO on Sept. 3. The agreement was for Garcia to give “feedback” on their initial talks. Garcia never communicated to Liu nor to the Chinese Embassy in Manila.
On Aug. 23, with only a little over a week before the event, the Chinese Foreign Ministry informed the Philippine Embassy in Beijing, through Deputy Chief of Mission Antonio Morales, that since there were no preliminary meetings on the President’s proposed trip to Nanning, China “can’t guarantee that it would be fruitful.” It advised that Trade Secretary Gregory Domingo head the Philippine delegation.
On Aug. 28, the President announced that he was going on a one-day trip to Nanning. The next day, DFA released a text message to media that “The President has decided not to proceed to CAExpo taking into consideration China’s request for the President to visit China at a more conducive time. “
The DFA Q&A said, “In all matters of foreign policy importance, the President is regularly advised in a timely and confidential manner.”
Relations between the Philippines and China have been strained since the April 2013 standoff in Scarborough shoal, which is being claimed by both countries. The shoal, which is 124 nautical miles off Zambales, is now under the control of China and inaccessible to Philippine vessels.
The Philippines has filed a suit before the United Nations Arbitral Court questioning China’s 9-dash line map which covers almost the whole of South China Sea including territories of other countries including the Philippines.
Following is the DFA’s full Q & A on the CAEXPO
Was the President invited?
The annual China-ASEAN Exposition (CAEXPO) is an ASEAN-China cooperative event and the usual practice is for the leader of the country of honor to be present. ASEAN countries had strongly urged the Philippines to send the country’s highest official to highlight the 10th anniversary of the ASEAN-China strategic partnership this year. Although the President does not need to be specifically invited, the documents we have on the DFA website will show that he was, in fact, invited.
Were there any concerns and conditions from China for the President’s attendance?
There were subsequent concerns and conditions to the President’s attendance and such conditions were absolutely inimical to our national interest. To avoid embarrassment on the Chinese side, we will not state these conditions but you may wish to address this specific question to H.E. Ambassador Ma Keqing.
Under what circumstances were these conditions conveyed?
These concerns and conditions were delivered by at least three Chinese Foreign Ministry sources. We were advised that these conditions (1) should not be made public and (2) should not be discussed at Ministerial level.
Given the unusual request and the importance of the issue involving our President, it was necessary for the conditions to be confirmed by the two Foreign Ministers at their meeting in Beijing last Wednesday, 28 August 2013.
Did the President accept these conditions?
The President stood firm in the defense of the country’s national interest.
Was the President given appropriate and timely advice on the issue?
As in all matters of foreign policy importance, the President is regularly advised in a timely and confidential manner.
(VERA Files is put out by veteran journalists taking a deeper look at current issues. Vera is Latin for “true.”)
Ano nga tawag dyan, diplomatic faux pas?
Big time, napahiya si Noynoy. Mukha pa namang atat na atat siya na makabiyahe sa Tsina.
Nobody from DFA wants to follow NBI chief Rojaz who tendered an irrevocable resignation because Pnoy said NBI “has its share of ‘less trustworthy’ officials and agents under Dir. Nonnatus Rojas.”
So, dapat i-fire ni Pnoy ang mga opisyal sa DFA at si Trade Sec Trade Sec Gregory Domingo na nagpahiya sa kanya kung ayaw magsipag-irrevocable resignation. Gayahin nila ang ipinahiya ni Noy sa NBI, lumayas kaagad sa position dahil sa kadaldalan ng pangulo just to save face why the royal treatment of Napoles.
No matter what the issue of “unacceptable condition”, the reason DFA now tells the public why the president’s China trip was cancelled, fact is Pnoy’s face is all yellow due to losing face. Nakakahiya, lumalabas hindi siya respetado ng Tsina dahil lang sa ang kanyang mga opisyales were not paying attention.
Granting that the China set conditions for the visit (report is the withdrawal of Philippine suit at the UN Arbitral Court), the question still is, did they tell Aquino about it?
If they told Aquino about it, why was he announcing up to Aug. 28 his Nanning visit when China had already canceled the visit Aug. 23?
China does not have the monopoly of setting conditions. We are also demanding from China that they pull out of Scarborough Shoal.
I always wonder about the motivations of Filipinos, who understanding there is a conflict underway between China and the Philippines, criticize the Philippines but not China.
China is a thug and anything the Philippines does, other than bow and do what China wants, will be criticized by China. Let’s go to the source of the problem, go to the source, the source . . . It is China, not DFA or Aquino.
Bilateral agreement in Chinese political-speak means “you inconsequential Filipinos bow to us”.
China has been known to only come and sit on the table if the other party can match its bluff.. And PM Harper did when Canada has a Human Right issue with one of China national holding a Canadian Citizenship…PM Harper told China bluntly that his Govt. can not deal with a Regime that do not respect another country’s right to Protect its own national.. China loaned us two of its Giant Panda that are now Both the Star Attraction at the Toronto Zoo…and they are Thirsting for the oil that they may soon see shipped if the US DILLYdally with the Construction of more Pipelines.. Saskatchewan has not started squeezing its sand oil just as yet and it is said that the Sand Oil of Saskatchewan is just as massive as Alberta…we’d rather sell it to India, a much Friendlier nation..but again look what India did with Our Nuclear Tech?
Pahiya talaga, Chi.#1. Will there be changes in the Cabinet?